Wuthering heights and jane eyre from the worlds largest community of readers. Wuthering heights begins in the present and then jane eyre wuthering heights. Comparison of jane eyre and wuthering heights, sample of. Her courage is tested once again when she arrives at thornfield hall, where she has been hired by the brooding, proud edward roches. Byronic heroes are also a big part of both books, but emily picked an even darker path for her story compared to charlotte. The influence of mysticism in jane eyre and wuthering heights the bronte sisters can without doubt be called some of the greatest romantic writers of all.
Just like jane eyre, wuthering heights by emily bronte has gone on to become a classic, despite being very controversial for its time. Jane eyrewuthering heights books compared librarything. First of all i have to say that i like both books but i prefer jane eyre, which is a book that you could underestimate about its storyline, but instead you end up admiring and loving its heroine and the progress she makes despite oppositions. A poor governess, jane eyre, captures the heart of her enigmatic employer, edward rochester. In jane eyre it is moor house, and thornfield, while in wuthering heights it is the titular country house. Though only posthumously published in 1817, jane austens northanger abbey was the first that she ever wrote it was completed in 1803 and is a great option for those who are looking for some novels like jane eyre. Jane eyre, shirley, villette, and the professor by charlotte bronte and wuthering heights by emily bronte are included in this new addition to the library of literary classics. Librarything is a cataloging and social networking site for booklovers. In alison floods recent blog about the books she remembers most vividly from school, she mentioned that jane eyre bored her, but that the melodrama of wuthering heights kept her enthralled. What are some romance books like jane eyre or pride and. Thriftbooks sells millions of used books at the lowest everyday prices. If you enjoy the gothic feel of jane eyre, along with the romantic. This book is available for free download in a number of formats including epub, pdf, azw, mobi and more. Wuthering heights casts a gloom over the mind not easily to be dispelled.
Jane eyre without a doubt all that larking about in the rain banging on windows most undignified in wuthering heights. We personally assess every book s quality and offer rare, outofprint treasures. Like jane eyre, this is not your typical love story and maybe even might go. Jane eyre vs wuthering heights smackdown a guest entry. Throughout the two books, there are several recurring themes that stand out the most. Published in 1847, wuthering heights was brontes only novel and it follows many of the same plot points and themes as the works of her sisters. Maybe you like one and love the other, but you cant adore both books, they are fundamentally opposed on so many levels. Theres just something about jane eyre, and, like many beloved novels. Rosalie thinks she can steal mr weston from agnes, because, like tom. The only thing i didnt like about it was cathy, i didnt like her at all.
The portrayals of love and romance in charlottes jane eyre and emilys wuthering heights highlight the deeper difference between the themes of these two books and the worldviews of the women who. Last but by no means least, the third bronte sister to enter the list of books like wuthering heights is charlotte bronte s highly acclaimed gothic romance, jane eyre. I enjoyed reading jane eyre and i thought the story was really good, but i prefer the darker theme of wuthering heights. Theres just something about jane eyre, and, like many beloved. Orphaned as a child, jane has felt an outcast her whole young life. In retrospect, i think i wouldve enjoyed wuthering heights more if i had that mindset going in. I think wuthering heights is a must read for anyone interested in british literature and those who are interested in women writers. Agnes is a quieter heroine than jane eyre or wuthering heightss. Two volume box set with slip case by random house emily bronte, charlotte bronte, wood engravings by fritz eichenberg on. If you like jane eyre by charlotte bronte central rappahannock. The novel follows the punished orphan jane as she navigates her way through life from escaping her cruel aunt, mrs reed to surviving the horrors of a wicked school for orphans. You can also read the full text online using our ereader. Includes the major works by one of the greatest names in literature. Absolutely no list of books like jane eyre would be complete without including the other most famous novel from the bronte sisters, emily brontes wuthering heights.
I think all the histrionics in wuthering heights seem a bit ott to me now, but they chimed pretty well with all my melodramatic adolescent angst i guess. Wuthering heights is emily brontes only published novel. Jane eyre seems more focused on superstitious stuff and the scary aspect of things such as the odd laughing while wuthering heights was more in depth. I loved jane eyre, but am left mostly cold by wuthering heights, except for what i suspect will be a lingering irritation at the actions of the main characters. Jane eyre recounts the story of a governess who, having suffered during childhood both at her aunts house and then at school, finds herself falling for her new employer, mr. I expected a romance like jane eyre which i greatly enjoyed, and ended up being extremely confused for about 75% of the book, wondering when the great romance was going to happen. Ten remarkable novels for fans of jane eyre silver petticoat. The two novels that are considered their greatest masterpieces are wuthering heights and jane eyre. What you feel about wuthering heights, i feel about both books. Told in the first person by an english tutor in brussels, it is based on charlottes experiences there, with a reversal of sexes and roles. When i first read both novels as a teenager, i loved jane eyre more, but, on rereading them as an adult, i realised how brilliant wuthering heights is. I prefer wuthering heights since jane eyre almost feels like reading a childs book at the simplicity of the writing. For those who love jane eyre, i recommend ten other great novels to read. Only after newby offered the american rights of the tenant as having been written by the author of the successful jane eyre, did the sisters acknowledge their identities to their publishers.
Wuthering heights was published after jane eyres success, and i think it would be a mistake to hold the same to the same standard. The novel follows, unsurprisingly, the orphaned jane eyre as she. Check out our list of books like wuthering heights. Jane eyre is a book which affects the reader to tears. Find books like wuthering heights from the worlds largest community of readers. Jane eyre has all the classic elements the mystery of the attic the orphan girl who is nobodys fool. Join our community of taste explorers to save your discoveries, create inspiring lists, get personalized recommendations, and follow. Charlottes first novel, the professor published posthumously, 1857, shows her sober reaction from the indulgences of her girlhood. If you like wuthering heights you might like similar books jane eyre, pride and prejudice, sense and sensibility, great expectations, little women. If you like jane eyre you might like similar books wuthering heights, sense and sensibility, pride and prejudice, emma, little women.
Then make sure to check out our list of books like wuthering heights. Jane eyre which book is more enjoyable jane eyre or. Last but by no means least, the third bronte sister to enter the list of books like wuthering heights is charlotte. All of these books would be good next steps for readers intrigued by wuthering heights. I was captivated by heathcliff, hes probably one of the most interesting characters ive read. This seems to be the response opposite to the majority. The most telling tipoff occurs at the end of chapter 17, when rochester nearly calls jane my love before biting his tongue. As a teenager, its harder to follow but as an adult you really appreciate its courage. Goodreads members who liked wuthering heights also liked. I liked wuthering heights much more as a teenager, and jane eyre much more now i am an adult.
568 567 139 1265 1113 604 588 320 1182 1090 436 17 327 1404 33 1117 1447 1351 1483 1387 32 372 424 573 207 967 1175 1281 1150 180 1163 442 590 557 767 1034 1375 747 1032 343 1492 1378